Russia: We Should’ve Seen it Coming
Posted by StormWarning on 16 Aug 2008 at 07:09 am | Tagged as: Afghanistan, Commentary, Current Affairs, Economics, International Issues, Opinions, Russia
Not only should we have seen it coming, but its all about the oil. OK, sure, Putin wants to flex the Russian bear’s muscles, but its oil, its economics, and its another instance of shortsightedness in World affairs.
First, the missed signals and the opportunity to have acted sooner (rather than the later…in this case, the “cow/bear is out of the barn”). Anne Applebaum from the Washington Post once again and very pointedly describes the core issue in A Threat Explodes In Georgia.
Russia, by contrast, is an unpredictable power, which makes responding to Moscow more difficult. In fact, Russian politics have become so utterly opaque that it is not easy to say why this particular “frozen” conflict has escalated right now.
Most importantly (read the whole article please) is this:
In any case, the time to deal with this conflict is not now but was two, or even four, years ago. For a very long time it has been clear that there was a security vacuum in the Caucasus; that this vacuum was dangerous; that war was likely; that Georgia, an eager ally of the United States, would not emerge well from a confrontation; and that a successful invasion of Georgia, a country with U.S. troops on its soil, would reflect badly on the West. Cowardice, weakness, lack of ideas and, above all, the distraction of other events prevented any deeper engagement. And now it may be too late.
This is the very same Anne Applebaum whom I quoted in a previous post on June 9, 2007:
Cold War? What Cold War? - Just what is happening in Russia these days, and why is it that Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice, clearly a very intelligent and qualified person, can actually state “I have a difficult time explaining that speech. It doesn’t accord with either the world as we see it nor with the character of our interactions with the Russians.” Something just doesn’t make sense, and I believe that it goes beyond the subtlety of Anne Applebaum’s article in the Washington Post, Our Strange Devotion to the Kremlin.
Now, about the motivations and “its the oil stupid!” As I observed the other day in Uncle Vlad, etc.:
Cold war with missiles aimed at each other? Probably or maybe not. Nuclear diplomacy? Watch and see, There is a reason for Putin and Ahmadinejad playing with eachother sub-rosa. But its more likely about the oil (”stupid”) and about Putin seeing the economic power of the European Union. I suspect that he literally sees a reforming of the Soviet Union as a means to the end of economic power, as well as a re-emergence of Russia as a World power.
In an event likely to be related to the Russian invasion of Ossetia, the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline was struck by PKK (Kurdish Workers Party):
The BTC pipeline was hit by an explosion on Turkish territory on Aug. 5, two days before the conflict began over the South Ossetia region and the oil flow had halted. Turkish officials and the operator company, BP, had said the line was not affected by the conflict between Georgia and Russia.
AND (IMPORTANTLY)
An adviser to the Russian parliament also claimed the closed pipeline would not be opened again and declared the line is “dead”.
“The world and countries in the region have seen that not NATO, but Russia is the only one who could secure the energy routes,” Alexander Dugin, international politics advisor to the Russia’s Duma, told Turkish Cumhuriyet daily.
“In this context, regarding Turkey’s energy politics, it should be said that the BTC is not running at the moment and it will not run again.”
Have you any doubts? Consider this. I don’t work for the gov’t or any analyst group (although I do write “real” articles elsewhere). Why is it so clear (and has been for quite some time) to me that Russia through Putin’s aspirations was about to re-assert itself, when the Administration, even as recently as this week, can say that the times of the Cold War are over? Don’t believe this? Here:
“The cold war is over,” President Bush declared Friday, but a new era of enmity between the United States and Russia has emerged nevertheless. It may not be as tense as the nuclear standoff with the Soviet Union, for now, but it could become as strained.
Russia’s military offensive into Georgia has shattered, perhaps irrevocably, the strategy of three successive presidential administrations to coax Russia into alliance with the West and integration into its institutions.
Cold War over? Think again! But, President Bush at his Crawford Ranch and elsewhere has said of Putin, “I call him Vladimir.”
Its so plain and simple…as written in the NY Post article, Raping Georgia:
The Kremlin is determined to break Georgia’s will - and keep the feisty republic out of NATO.
Russia, you see, still believes it’s entitled to all of its former empire. And, tragically, “Old Europe” is back: Yesterday, Germany and other nervous European states bought the Russian line that Georgia is the aggressor. Wouldn’t want to anger Moscow…
While we see Russian tanks and aggression, it is, ultimately, about oil and economics, and about Uncle Vladimir re-asserting the power and influence of the once (and future) “mighty Russian bear” as a pseudo-Super Power. Other material available in Right Truth’s discussion of Russia’s invasion of Georgia, here.






I don’t know where Applebaum has been the last year or so, but this was not unexpected. First of all, a proper look at what actually happened is in order:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_Ossetia
South Ossetia had considered itself independent of Georgia since the early 90’s.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/europe/article4491738.ece
Georgia attacked Ossetia, Russia said it was defending Ossetia’s independence. Georgia then attacked Russian troops and declared a state of war with Russia, while claiming they had shot down 10 or so Russian jets. Evidence seems to support that claim.
The issue to this point was pretty much ignored by the world. The United States, very publicly, demanded Georgia cease-fire and not antagonize Russia.
Georgia refused. Russia then responded by marching straight to Tbilisi and pretty much wiping out the entire Georgian military.
The world then got upset. Bloggers and media ignored everything leading up to Russia in Tbilisi and blamed it all on Bush.
The reason I think Bush has refused to state this is a return of the Cold War is because Russia had justification in doing what it did and if he pushed it any farther over an “ally” that refused to do what everyone was telling them they needed to do, the real Cold War could indeed become hot again.
If one truly considers ALL of the events that have occurred, they would agree that truly the best thing the United States can do in this situation is mitigate the damages to Georgia and that region by getting Russia to pull out voluntarily. And, privately, tell that idiot Georgian president the next time he wants to settle an internal dispute that involves Russia, do it through the UN or NATO. If Russia had felt it truly was engaging a unified NATO, this would never have happened.
Russia over-reacted. However, it may well have settled the South Ossetia issue for a long time.
That entire region of the world is very volatile. South Ossetia is no different than Iraq, Pakistan, Iran, Palestine, or several other areas ready to blow itself up rather than discuss in a civilized manner. The only thing that they respect is brute power. Russia is a stabilizing force in the west, China to the east. What Bush realizes, and I do as well, is there has to be a muscleman to keep some semblence of sanity in those regions. That’s why in his opinion, the Cold War is over. It is mine as well. We can’t police the entire planet, and I don’t want to. It’s obvious the UN can’t do it. I don’t fully agree with how Russia handled Georgia, they went too far. However, if they honor the cease-fire and retreat starting tomorrow, then I think we have to respect them a little more than what people are willing to right now based solely on the actions of the last few days while ignoring the previous week.
Either that, or do expect another Cold War, and do expect to have our troops strung out all over the planet incapable of handling any small conflict in far, far, away places.
Thanks for the mention as always. Yes it is about oil for Russia, also for pride.
The events of today will be very revealing. Russia has already indicated that it will not withdraw from breakaway regions. In fact, today’s Washington Times is beginning to raise the doubts that Russia will do what it said it would do.
For his part, John Bolton (and others) is calling for Georgia to be accepted into NATO (for whatever good that would do).
I suspect that today will be a day to judge what will happen next as events unfold.
PS: Given the comments from history (going back 18 months at least), I believe that this Administration has underestimated Vladimir’s intentions. So personally, I think that Applebaum is right.